- 28 Oct 2024 - 02:29(02:29 GMT)
Thanks for joining us
- 28 Oct 2024 - 02:20(02:20 GMT)
Here’s what happened today
This live page will soon be closing. Here’s what happened today:
- Trump has rallied at Madison Square Garden, where he retread the major themes of his campaign to rally his base in the final stretch before election day.
- Harris has spent the day in Pennsylvania, where she struck an optimistic tone but warned of the “high stakes” of the upcoming vote.
- Comments made by a comedian at Trump’s New York rally have sparked outrage among Latino artists and civil rights groups, with Puerto Ricans representing a potential key voting bloc in some swing states.
- More than 41 million Americans have already cast their ballots in this year’s election, according to the Election Lab at the University of Florida.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 02:10(02:10 GMT)
Comedian’s dig at Puerto Rico at Trump rally sparks outrage
Tony Hinchcliffe’s remarks – in which, as we reported earlier, he called Puerto Rico an “island of garbage” – have been widely condemned by several Latino organisations and legislators.
The criticism may also give a boost to Harris, who earlier today posted a video online in support of Puerto Rico.
After Hinchcliffe’s joke, that Harris campaign video was shared by Bad Bunny, a Puerto Rican rapper and singer, as well as artists Jennifer Lopez and Ricky Martin. Together, the trio have 341 million Instagram followers.
There are also large Puerto Rican populations in the key swing states of North Carolina, Georgia and Pennsylvania.
Luis Fonsi, who sang Despacito, trashed Tony Hinchcliffe calling Puerto Rico an “island of garbage” and said it’s “Una falta de respeto,” which means “it’s a lack of respect.” He also shared Kamala Harris’s video talking about Puerto Rico. pic.twitter.com/rte4Nb4Art
— Eric Michael Garcia (@EricMGarcia) October 27, 2024
Advertisement - 28 Oct 2024 - 02:00(02:00 GMT)
Trump’s ‘insulting comments’ about Harris making headlines
But the reality is that the base support for both Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is essentially baked in.
Both [candidates], in national polls today, are at 48 percent.
This election is going to come down to places not like New York, but the seven swing states – several thousand voters are going to make the final verdict.
And it’s there that the candidates will concentrate their efforts in the last nine days of this election campaign.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 01:50(01:50 GMT)
Biden to vote tomorrow
Biden is set to cast his ballot tomorrow in his home state of Delaware, according to the White House.
Delaware is a Democratic stronghold and Biden served as its senator from 1973 to 2009.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 01:40(01:40 GMT)
Michigan, at a glance
Harris will be rallying tomorrow in Ann Arbor, Michigan – a key battleground state.
Here’s what you need to know about the swing state:
- Population: More than 10 million
- Electoral College votes: 15
- Who won in 2020? Democrat Joe Biden
- What was the margin of victory? Biden had 50.6 percent of the vote compared with 47.8 percent for Trump
- Did you know? Trump’s 2016 victory in the state over Democrat Hillary Clinton was the first time a Republican candidate had won Michigan since 1992.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 01:30(01:30 GMT)
Trump campaign claims it is about to sell 3 millionth MAGA hat
In an email to supporters, the Trump campaign has said it is selling “what might be our 3 millionth MAGA hat in history”.
The hat – which was originally red but is also sold in Black and other colours – has become ubiquitous in US politics since 2016.
The campaign called it a “historic milestone”.

A MAGA hat in Waco, Texas [File: Nathan Howard/AP Photo] - 28 Oct 2024 - 01:20(01:20 GMT)
Federal appeals court upholds reversal of Virginia voter purge
A federal appeals court judge has upheld a ruling that blocked state officials from automatically purging voters from registration rolls on suspicion they are non-citizens.
The effort had been struck down due to a federal law that prevents such moves within 90 days of an election.
The Department of Justice and voting rights organisations had challenged the purge, arguing it threatened to ensnare citizens with the legal right to vote.
Republicans have increasingly pushed claims of widespread non-citizen voting in the US, which is illegal. But several audits by both state authorities and independent experts have found instances of such voting are exceedingly rare.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 01:10(01:10 GMT)
Trump whipping up fear among his supporters: Professor
Jennifer Mercieca, a professor at A&M University, has noted that Trump has been playing up a sense of fear among his supporters to get them to rally around him.
“The way that you take over a democracy and turn it authoritarian or turn it fascist, is that you use just [a] constant and widespread fear of things,” Mercieca said during an online panel organised by the Lincoln Project, a pro-democracy group critical of the ex-president.
“Essentially, what Trump has done is terrorise his followers… They are walking around, looking at the world as if they are constantly being threatened,” she said during the town hall.
“As you hear Trump’s messages, they are about creating hate objects, but it’s really terrorising his followers so that they will submit to him, which is what he wants.”
Advertisement - 28 Oct 2024 - 01:00(01:00 GMT)
Where is Trump campaigning next?
The Republican will be holding a rally in Atlanta, Georgia, on Monday.
Trump lost the key battleground state to Democrat Joe Biden by a narrow-thin margin in 2020.
The 2020 results marked the first time a Democratic presidential candidate had won in Georgia since 1992.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 00:50(00:50 GMT)
‘We will make America great again’: Trump ends speech in New York
Trump has delivered a long and meandering address, or what he refers to as his “weave”.
He made sweeping promises: “We stand on the verge of the greatest four years in US history.”
And launched into familiar attacks: “Kamala Harris is a radical left Marxist rated even worse than crazy Bernie Sanders or Pocahontas.”
He also inserted a few minutes of the truly strange: “I am under investigation more than the late great Al Capone.”
All told, Trump painted a picture of a country in economic and social crisis and portrayed himself to his base as their only saviour.
“November 5 will be the most important date in the history of our country, and together, we will make America powerful again,” Trump said in his final statements.
“We will make America wealthy again. We will make America healthy again. We will make America strong again. We will make America proud again… And we will make America great again,” he said, walking off the stage to Frank Sinatra’s New York, New York.

Trump and his wife Melania Trump react during the rally at Madison Square Garden [Carlos Barria/Reuters] - 28 Oct 2024 - 00:40(00:40 GMT)
‘The Big Lie’: How many Americans still reject 2020 election results?
A lot, according to a September 2023 survey by the Public Religion Research Institute.
The survey found that 32 percent of Americans believed the 2020 election was stolen from Trump.
But when you break it down by party affiliation, there was a stark difference: Sixty-six percent of Republicans believe the “Big Lie” that the 2020 election was stolen, compared with just 6 percent of Democrats, the survey said.
Trump continues to falsely claim that the 2020 vote that he lost to Democratic President Biden was stolen through widespread fraud.
That includes tonight in New York City, where he said “they used COVID to cheat”.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 00:30(00:30 GMT)
What is the Harris campaign highlighting from Trump’s speech?
The Democratic candidate’s campaign has been responding in real-time to Trump’s speech.
Here are the lines Harris’s camp is highlighting to make the argument that Trump is unfit to serve as president:
- The campaign posted a clip of Trump broadly portraying Democrats as the “enemy within”.
- They also posted a clip of Trump calling two of his former generals, Mark Milley and James Mattis – who have become vocal critics of the former president – “stupid”.
- Finally, they seized on Trump’s promise to invoke a 1798 law to carry out mass deportations.
“Trump says he wants to bring back laws from the 1700s,” the campaign said.

Harris gives a speech during a campaign rally in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, October 27 [Eloisa Lopez/Reuters] - 28 Oct 2024 - 00:20(00:20 GMT)
More than 41 million Americans have already voted
That’s according to a tally by the Election Lab at the University of Florida.
About half of those early voters – more than 20 million Americans – cast their ballots during in-person voting while the other half voted via mail-in ballots.
- 28 Oct 2024 - 00:10(00:10 GMT)
Photos: Trump supporters turn out for New York speech

[Andrew Kelly/Reuters] 
Trump supporters cheer as they watch a live transmission of Trump’s speech, outside Madison Square Garden, in New York [David Dee Delgado/Reuters] 
[David Dee Delgado/Reuters] - 28 Oct 2024 - 00:00(00:00 GMT)
Trump vs Harris: Who do Americans trust to handle economy?
With both Trump and Harris pledging to bring down costs for Americans, the economy remains at the heart of the election campaign.
Trump has the edge over Harris on the issue, according to a Gallup survey from early October.
The survey suggested that 54 percent of respondents believe Trump would do a better job of handling the economy than Harris, compared with 45 percent who favour the Democrat.
“While the economy often ranks as one of the top voting issues in presidential elections, this year it may be more influential than in any election since 2008 during the Great Recession,” Gallup said.
“Trump is favored over Harris to better handle the issue, giving him a significant advantage in the election, though this is partly influenced by Republicans being more likely than Democrats to rate the economy as an extremely important issue.”
- 27 Oct 2024 - 23:50(23:50 GMT)
It’s all Trump’s greatest hits at MSG
Trump has hardly broken new ground on stage in New York, instead repeating the claims – many of them false – that have defined his campaign for months.
Here’s what he has said so far:
- Promised to “build the greatest economy in the history of the world”, end inflation, stop the “invasion of criminals coming into our country” and “bring back the American dream”;
- Promised to cut taxes on tips, overtime and social security as he accuses Harris of “destroying the middle class”;
- Falsely claimed a “migrant invasion” is under way; pledged mass deportations and to impose the death penalty on migrants who kill US citizens or law enforcement officers;
- Derided US journalists in the room as “fake news”;
- Falsely claimed the Biden administration did not have money for hurricane recovery because it had spent too much on migrants;
- Claimed Russia would have never invaded Ukraine and Hamas would have never attacked southern Israel if he had been president.

Trump raises fist as he takes the stage at Madison Square Garden [Brendan McDermid/Reuters] Advertisement - 27 Oct 2024 - 23:40(23:40 GMT)
How many people are really crossing the US-Mexico border?
Amid Trump’s repeated claims that a “migrant invasion” is under way at the US-Mexico border, the data shows us that is untrue.
In September, the last month for which data is available, the US Border Patrol recorded about 53,900 “encounters” between ports of entry at the southwest border.
That’s 7 percent less than a month earlier and a 75 percent drop from September 2023.
The decrease is due in large part to the Biden administration’s tightening of restrictions at the border, including contentious curbs on the right to seek asylum. Mexico is also cracking down on migration as people try to reach the border.

Trump speaks along the southern border with Mexico in Arizona in August [Evan Vucci/AP Photo] - 27 Oct 2024 - 23:30(23:30 GMT)
Trump again attacks migrants, falsely claims ‘invasion’ under way
The Republican has falsely claimed – again – that his Democratic rival Harris “imported criminal migrants” into the US.
“She has resettled them into your communities to prey upon innocent American citizens,” he said, promising to crack down on migration if elected.
Rights advocates have condemned Trump’s incendiary, anti-migrant rhetoric as inciting violence against immigrant communities.
- 27 Oct 2024 - 23:25(23:25 GMT)
Trump touts economic plan, including tax credit for ‘family caretakers’
In true Trumpian fashion, the former president has promised to “build the greatest economy in the history of the world”.
He touted his economic proposals, which include cutting taxes for overtime and tips, as well as on social security benefits. He also introduced a new proposal to give tax credits to “family caretakers” of loved ones, without providing much more detail.
On energy, he said, “We’re going to drill, baby drill.”
Trump also again pledged to impose tariffs to force more companies to boost domestic manufacturing.
“We’re going to protect our companies. They’re not leaving any more,” he said.

Trump walks on stage at Madison Square Garden, October 27 [Carlos Barria/Reuters]
US election updates: Trump at Madison Square Garden, Harris in Pennsylvania
These were the updates on the 2024 US election campaign for Sunday, October 27.

Trump courts Muslim voters as Kamala Harris holds rival rally in Michigan
Published On 27 Oct 2024
This live page is now closed.
- Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump has rallied his Make America Great Again (MAGA) base at Madison Square Garden in New York City.
- Democratic contender Kamala Harris has stressed the “high stakes” of the US election during a day of campaigning in the key swing state of Pennsylvania.
- Trump pledges to tackle inflation and crack down on immigration at New York rally; Harris says in CBS interview her first priority as president would be to reverse abortion restrictions.
- Polls continue to show an extremely tight race between the two candidates, less than two weeks before election day on November 5.



